Amazon sellers are always looking for the best way to drive traffic to their listings. The big debate? Amazon PPC vs. External Traffic. While Amazon Pay-Per-Click (PPC) advertising is an internal system designed to boost product visibility within Amazon, external traffic sources like Google Ads, social media marketing, and email campaigns can also bring in potential buyers. But which strategy delivers the best results? Let’s break it down with a case study, key comparisons, and expert insights.

Understanding Amazon PPC

Amazon PPC (Pay-Per-Click) allows sellers to bid on keywords and display their products in prominent locations within Amazon’s search results.

How It Works:

1. Sellers bid on specific keywords relevant to their product.
2. When a shopper searches for those keywords, Amazon’s algorithm determines which ads to show based on relevance, bid amount, and ad performance.
3. The seller pays a fee each time a shopper clicks on their ad.

Pros of Amazon PPC:

• Direct Buyer Intent – People searching on Amazon are already looking to buy, increasing the chances of conversion.
• Boosts Organic Ranking – Running PPC campaigns can increase visibility and sales velocity, which helps with organic rankings.
• Multiple Ad Types – Sponsored Products, Sponsored Brands, and Sponsored Display offer different ways to target customers at various stages of the buying journey.
• Amazon’s Algorithm Advantage – The A9 algorithm prioritizes products with high conversion rates and steady ad traffic, leading to better organic placement.
• Immediate Sales Impact – Amazon PPC can generate quick sales, making it ideal for product launches and maintaining sales momentum.

Cons of Amazon PPC:

• Rising Costs – Due to high competition, CPC (Cost-Per-Click) rates are increasing, especially in popular niches.
• Limited Audience Expansion – PPC only targets people already searching within Amazon, meaning customer reach is restricted.
• Short-Term Impact – Once you stop PPC ads, traffic slows down unless you have strong organic rankings.
• Complex Campaign Management – Effective PPC management requires constant monitoring, bid adjustments, and A/B testing to avoid wasted ad spend.

Understanding External Traffic: Google, Social Media, and Email Marketing

External traffic sources allow sellers to attract customers from outside Amazon, such as Google Ads, Facebook/Instagram Ads, influencer marketing, and email campaigns.

How It Works:

1. Sellers create ads or campaigns on platforms like Google, Facebook, or Instagram, targeting potential customers based on interests, demographics, and online behavior.
2. These ads drive traffic to the Amazon listing or an external landing page.
3. Amazon’s algorithm rewards listings that bring in external traffic, improving ranking and visibility.

Pros of External Traffic:

• Cheaper Clicks (Potentially) – In some cases, CPC on Google and Facebook can be lower than Amazon PPC.
• Brand Building – Social media and email marketing help develop long-term customer relationships beyond Amazon.
• Diversified Audience – External traffic allows you to tap into new audiences who might not be actively searching on Amazon.
• Amazon’s Favoritism Toward External Sales – Amazon rewards sellers with higher rankings when they bring in external traffic, as it expands Amazon’s reach.
• Retargeting Potential – Facebook and Google allow sellers to retarget past visitors, increasing conversion opportunities.

Cons of External Traffic:

• Lower Buyer Intent – Users from Facebook or Google might not be actively looking to buy, leading to lower conversion rates.
• Learning Curve – Mastering Google Ads, Facebook targeting, and email marketing takes time, and mistakes can be costly.
• Tracking Limitations – Amazon doesn’t provide detailed conversion tracking for external sources like it does for PPC, making ROI analysis harder.
• Amazon Attribution Delays – While Amazon Attribution allows tracking of external traffic, data can take days to update, making real-time campaign adjustments difficult.

Case Study: Amazon PPC vs. External Traffic

Let’s examine a real-world example of an Amazon seller running Amazon PPC vs. External Traffic through Facebook Ads and Google Ads.

Product: Organic Vitamin C Serum

• Campaign Duration: 30 Days
• Ad Spend: $1,000 on each channel

Key Takeaways:

• Amazon PPC had the highest conversion rate (15%) due to high buyer intent.
• Google Ads performed better than Facebook Ads in terms of conversion, likely because Google searches show stronger intent than social media browsing.
• Facebook Ads generated the most clicks, but had the lowest conversion rate, proving that social traffic may need better nurturing through retargeting and email follow-ups.
• Amazon PPC had the best return on investment (ROI), making it the most efficient option for immediate sales.

What Works Best for Your Business?

The right strategy depends on your goals:

• If you want fast, scalable sales, start with Amazon PPC since it targets high-intent buyers actively searching for products.
• If you’re building brand awareness, use Facebook and Instagram ads to grow your audience and create a loyal customer base.
• If you want long-term growth, leverage Google Ads and email marketing to nurture customer relationships and drive consistent sales over time.
• For the best results? Use a mix of both. Many top sellers combine Amazon PPC with external traffic to maximize sales, brand exposure, and ranking benefits.

Final Thoughts

The battle between Amazon PPC vs. External Traffic doesn’t have a one-size-fits-all answer. Amazon PPC is essential for short-term conversions, while external traffic sources help build brand awareness and long-term customer loyalty. Smart sellers use a combination of both to balance immediate sales with sustainable growth.

What’s Your Experience?

Have you tested Amazon PPC vs. external traffic? Comment below and let us know what worked best for you.

References & Further Reading:

• Amazon Advertising Official Guide
• Google Ads Guide for E-commerce
• Facebook Business Ads Guide
• Amazon Ranking Factors & External Traffic Insights

Need help optimizing your Amazon ads? Contact us today for expert PPC and marketing strategies.